Originally posted by Vanguard:
I don't really care how good it may seem to others, but I am sick of franchises,and remakes. I mean, to me it is just another sign that people are to afraid of something new.
As a note, remakes
are something new. If you've ever watched the original Battlestar Galactica, you'll probably note that the current version doesn't
actually have a lot in common with it. You've got the basic plot, and some basic character archetypes, but everything else is entirely reimagined. Remakes are rarely
exactly the same as the original, for that would be stupid - the idea is to use the original as a base to create a new piece of work.
Similarly with SG-1. There's actually literally nothing similar between the two except for two characters, and one stargate. That's literally about it.
Stargate was mostly a sci-fi flick about humans messing with stuff they don't understand, and helping to save a world the good old american way (with a big explosion!).
SG-1, on the other hand, is more a rollicking good adventure series highlighting the need for human exploration, for better or for worse. They're rarely messing with things they don't understand, because usually someone figures it out pretty quickly.
The CSIs are a slightly different case, but I state that even if the premises are identical, they are three completely different shows. Each has a very distinct feel about it and has somewhat different character interactions (even if the leads are all virtually identical). I know a lot of people who aren't fond of CSI Miami, but love the other two. I have to admit, I kinda agree - CSI Miami just rubs me the wrong way.
But then, remember that there can't be anything original on television these days - Pop culture is so pervasive that every idea you come up with is going to be influenced by some other Pop culture ideology. What people attempt to do these days to come with fresh concepts is to take an old concept, and do something new with it. Personally, I think that's justifiable. The road is just as important as the car you're driving it on...