|
|
#92072 - 07/13/07 11:01 AM
Re: Table Talk: The Long March
[Re: Andrew Murphy]
|
Baseline
Registered: 05/28/07
Posts: 44
|
Bradford will basically be doing the following for the next year: 1) Study "history" (future to him  ) to find out what the hell goes wrong in the other time lines, and using this info, work with the others to achieve their goals. 2) Study language texts. He only knows German and English, so he would like to be as fluent as possible in as many languages as possible. 3) Study and observe a variety of weapons in action (video footage, or possible visits to weapons experts of the era) in order to make any "combat" illusions more realistic. 4) Talk with the novas and crew to glean knowledge of the future, including fads and "hip" slang. 5) Practicing his powers. 6) Put his swerve down on Lorean :P
|
|
Top
|
Reply
Quote
Quick Reply
Quick Quote
|
|
|
#93404 - 08/02/07 09:38 AM
Re: Table Talk: The Long March
[Re: jameson (ST)]
|
Nova
Registered: 09/27/06
Posts: 2950
Loc: Everywhere
|
Granted, Steve's idea is just that at this moment... but it's a start, and the alternatives don't seem to be better. Trying to blame Max, is going to be counter productive. That's also the case even if Andrew is right.
Whether Max's limitations are inherant to his powers or his personality don't really matter. Yes, if he had a different personality, and if his limiations are not part of his power, then it's *possible* that he could be a lot more useful. But there are a lot of "ifs" in that chain of logic and the being wrong could be very bad.
We have two bottom lines here. One is that we can't afford to antagonize Max. We need him on our side even if he's not going to help because god knows he could hurt us a lot. And BTW he just *did* help a lot with Divis. The other bottom line is that we have Lorean's word that her creators thought paradox would be dangerous to "her".
I lean strongly towards predestination myself. Immunity to his own powers and/or Paradox implies it.
The alternative appears to be he can make changes willynilly and remember the results. Which is fine until you realize his decades of experience then get multiplied by dozens, hundreds, or even thousands of timelines.
It'd get seriously confusing really quickly, and Max is protrayed as being decisive and not confused (as opposed to Herzog). And he'd still be a pocket calculator dealing with something out of his league. For all our computing power we can't even predict the weather.
EDIT: And if we're stuck on one timeline, then chances are Max is too.
_________________________
Hauling things through the sky.
|
|
Top
|
Reply
Quote
Quick Reply
Quick Quote
|
|
|
#93420 - 08/02/07 01:41 PM
Re: Table Talk: The Long March
[Re: Andrew Murphy]
|
Nova
Registered: 09/27/06
Posts: 2950
Loc: Everywhere
|
Problem is, even assuming the worst case synario, i.e. Max *did* cause all kinds of problems, it isn't what he was working for, nor were the root problems his doing. Failing to win isn't the same as causing the problem.
The problems that Max inflicted on the world were not of his own making, and are at worse failures of his in responding to the actual problem. This specifically includes Divis' relationship issues which I'm much more inclined to blame on Divis.
Problems the world faces: 1) Superhumans 2) Societies reaction to them. 3) Divis Mal or whatever his name is.
Max's solution was to try to get Divis to wear a white hat, and to form Utopia. These are not bad solutions, but they weren't implimented successfully. Max may have trained Thetis, but the solution to that problem is to do something about Thetis, not something about Max.
I don't see how we can judge Max more harshly than, say, Omar or Cody. Omar's love of attention is potentially a larger problem than Max's fear of paradox (a fear shared by Lorean BTW). Cody is already deep into Taint issues, and he's already started killing people.
Are we going to kill them too? The answer there is "maybe", but we should wait for actual problems rather than the potential for problems.
_________________________
Hauling things through the sky.
|
|
Top
|
Reply
Quote
Quick Reply
Quick Quote
|
|
|
|